Duty of Loyalty to the State or the ‘Polish Section’ in the 1937 Estonian Constitution
Keywords:
‘loyalty to the state’ section, 1935 Polish Constitution, 1937 Estonian Constitution, authoritarian regime of Konstantin PätsAbstract
There is a common comparison between the constitutions of the authoritarian regimes of Poland (1935) and Estonia (1937). The ideological model of the 1937 Estonian Constitution, especially in the section on loyalty to the state, was the 1935 Polish Constitution; for this reason, this section was also called the ‘Polish Section’. Compared to the first, 1920 Estonian Constitution, the 1937 Constitution was much more restrictive of basic rights, in particular through its general orientation and attitude. It was precisely in this that the so-called “loyalty to the state” section (§ 8) played a special role, affecting the whole chapter by its very nature, because it could, in its wording – and according to the example of Poland – constitute a general border clause on fundamental rights and freedoms. This article analyses specifically the ‘loyalty to the state’ section but first a short overview about historical background will be given. Secondly, the drafting of the section 8 of the Estonian Constitutions in the committees’ will be described and analysed, and thirdly, the discussions in the National Assembly will be summarized.
References
. 26803, [in:] Polnoe sobranie zakonov Rossijskoj Imperii, Sob 3, T. XXIV, Sankt Peterburg 1905 // 26803, [in:] Полное собрание законов Российской Империи, Соб 3, Т. XXIV, Санкт Петербург 1905.
. 27805, [in:] Polnoe sobranie zakonov Rossijskoj Imperii. Sob 3, T. XXVI, Otdelenie 1, Sankt Peterburg 1906 // 27805, [in:] Полное собрание законов Российской Империи. Соб 3, Т. XXVI, Отделение 1, Санкт Петербург 1906.
Anepaio T., Justice Laws of 1889 — a Step in Estonia’s Constitutional Development, “Juridica International” 2005/X.
Brzezinski M.F., Constitutional Heritage and Renewal: The Case of Poland, “Virginia Law Review” 1991, vol. 1 (77).
Constitution of the Republic of Estonia with the Decision of the Estonian People for convening the National Constituent Assembly and the Law for the Transition Period. Official edition, Tallinn 1937.
Constitution of the Republic of Poland, http://libr.sejm.gov.pl/tek01/txt/kpol/e1935-r1.html.
Constitution of the Republic of Poland, March 17, 1921. printed in: The new constitutions of Europe, eds. H.L. McBain, L. Rogers, Garden City 1922, http://libr.sejm.gov.pl/tek01/txt/kpol/e1921.html.
Eesti Vabariigi Pohiseadus [Constitution of the Republic of Estonia], [in:] NA ERA.31.3.735.
Eesti Vabariigi Pohiseadus [The Constitution of Republic of Estonia], “Riigi Teataja” [State Gazette] 1920, 113/114, 243.
Eesti Vabariigi Pohiseaduse I lugemisel, Rahvuskogu. Esimene koda [Reading of Constitution I of the Republic of Estonia, National Assembly. First Chamber], Tallinn 1937.
Hauser A., Kedzia Z., Poland: From the Golden Liberty of the Nobles to Fundamental Rights, [in:] First Fundamental Rights Documents in Europe, Eds. M. Suksi, K. Agapiou-Josephides, J.-P. Lehners, M. Nowak, Cambridge–Antwerp–Portland 2015.
Karjaharm T., Revolutsioon ja soda, [Revolution and War], [in:] Eesti ajalugu V. Parisorjuse kaotamisest Vabadussojani [Estonian History V. From the Abolition of Serfdom to the War of Independence], Tartu 2010.
Kasekamp A.I., The Rise of the Radical Right, the Demise of Democracy, and the Advent of Authoritarianism in Interwar Estonia, [in:] War, Revolution, and Governance: The Baltic Countries in the Twentieth Century, eds. L. Fleishman, A. Weiner, Boston, 2018.
Laaman E., Kodaniku pohioigused ja kohused [Fundamental rights and obligations of a citizen], [in:] Pohiseadus ja Rahvuskogu [The Constitution and the National Assembly], Tallinn 1937.
Laaman E., Rahvuskogu Esimese ja Teise Koja Pohiseaduse eelnou-osade komisjonide 2. uhine koosolek. 2. martsil 1937 [Second joint meeting of the Committees on draft parts of the Constitution of the First and Second Chambers of the National Assembly. On 2 March 1937], [in:] Rahvuskogu uldkoosolekute ja pohiseaduse eelnou-osade komisjonide uhiste koosolekute stenograafilised aruanded [Stenographical reports of the general meetings of the National Assembly and of the joint meetings of the Committees on draft parts of the Constitution], Tallinn 1938.
Laaman E., Solidarism ja selle rakendamine meie pohiseadustes [Solidarism and Its Implementation in our Constitutions], “Oigus” [The Law] 1938, vol 9.
Laamani paevik 1922-1940 [Laaman’s Diary 1922-1940], “Akadeemia” 2003, vol. 12; 2004, vol. 1; 2004, vol. 2.
Luts-Sootak M., Siimets-Gross H., Die “menschenwurdige Existenz” im Grundrechtskatalog des Grundgesetzes von 1920 der Estnischen Republik, [in:] Die rechtshistorische Exegese. Zugange und Methoden anhand von (Lieblings-)Quellen. Ein bunter Geburtstagsstraus mit 25 Blumen fur Joachim Ruckert zum 16. August 2020, T. Keiser, P. Oestmann, T. Pierson (Hrsg.), (in publication 2022).
Luts-Sootak M., Siimets-Gross H., Eine rechtmasige Diktatur? Estlands Verfassungsentwicklungen in der Zwischenkriegszeit des 20. Jahrhunderts, “Parliaments, Estates and Representation” 2021, vol. 41, 2.
Maddison E., Angelus O., Das Grundgesetz des Freistaats Estland, Berlin 1928.
Marandi R., Poola 1935. aasta konstitutsioon kui Eesti 1937. aasta pohiseaduse eeskuju [Poland’s 1935 Constitution as an example of Estonian’s 1937 Constitution], “Eesti TA Toim. Humanitaar- ja sotsiaalteadused” [proceedings of the Estonian Academy of Science. Humanities and Social Sciences] 1994/41, vol. 3.
Meder W., Das Dekretrecht des Staatsprasidenten in Estland, Tartu 1936.
Pajur A., Autoritaarne Eesti [Authoritarian Estonia], [in:] Eesti ajalugu VI. Vabadussojast taasiseseisvumiseni [Estonian history VI. From the Estonian War of Independence to Reindependence], Tartu 2005.
Pajur A., Konstantin Pats. Poliitiline biograafia. II osa: riigimees (1917–1956), [Konstantin Pats. Political biography. Part II: statesman (1917–1956)], Tartu 2018.
Piip A., Rahvuskogu Esimese ja Teise Koja Pohiseaduse eelnou-osade komisjonide 1. Uhine koosolek. 2. martsil 1937 [First joint meeting of the Committees on draft parts of the Constitution of the First and Second Chambers of the National Assembly. On 2 March 1937], [in:] Rahvuskogu uldkoosolekute ja pohiseaduse eelnou-osade komisjonide uhiste koosolekute stenograafilised aruanded [Stenographical reports of the general meetings of the National Assembly and of the joint meetings of the Committees on draft parts of the Constitution], Tallinn 1938.
Piip A., Rahvuskogu Esimese ja Teise Koja Pohiseaduse eelnou-osade komisjonide 3. Uhine koosolek. 3. martsil 1937 [Third joint meeting of the Committees on draft parts of the Constitution of the First and Second Chambers of the National Assembly. On 3 March 1937 ], [in:] Rahvuskogu uldkoosolekute ja pohiseaduse eelnou-osade komisjonide uhiste koosolekute stenograafilised aruanded [Stenographical reports of the general meetings of the National Assembly and of the joint meetings of the Committees on draft parts of the Constitution], Tallinn 1938.
Protokoll nr. 14. Riigivanema poolt maaratud Pohiseaduseelnou valjatootamise komisjoni koosolek kesknadalal 30. detsembril 1936 kell 5 pl. Riigikantselei koosolekute saalis [Minutes No 14. The meeting of the Committee for the Elaboration of the Draft Constitution, appointed by the State Elder, midweek on 30 December 1936 at 5 p.m. in the meeting room of the State Chancellery], [in:] Estonian National Archives ERA.31.3.735.
Protokoll nr. 2. Riigivanema poolt maaratud Pohiseaduse eelnou valjatootamise komisjoni koosolek esmaspaeval 14. detsembril 1936 kell 11 pl. Riigikantselei noupidamise saalis [Minutes No 2. Meeting of the Committee on the Development of the draft Constitution, appointed by the State Elder, on Monday 14 December 1936 at 11 pm in the State Chancellery’s meeting room], [in:] Estonian National Archives ERA.31.3.735. (not paginated).
Protokoll nr. 22. Riigivanema poolt maaratud Pohiseaduseelnou valjatootamise komisjoni koosolek laupaeval, 9. jaanuaril 1937 kell 5 pl. Riigikantselei koosolekute saalis [Minutes No 22. The meeting of the Committee for the Elaboration of the Draft Constitution, appointed by the State Elder, on Saturday 9 January 1937 at 5 p.m. in the meeting room of the State Chancellery], [in:] Estonian National Archives ERA.31.3.735.,l 125. This is also the case in the minutes of 17.1.1937.
Protokoll nr. 23. Riigivanema poolt maaratud Pohiseaduseelnou valjatootamise komisjoni koosolek puhapaeval, 10. jaanuaril 1937 kell 6 ohtul pl. Riigikantselei koosolekute saalis [Minutes No 23. The meeting of the Committee for the Elaboration of the Draft Constitution, appointed by the State Elder, on Sunday 10 January 1937 at 6 p.m. in the meeting room of the State Chancellery], [in:] Estonian National Archives ERA.31.3.735.
Protokoll nr. 41. Riigivanema poolt nimetatud Pohiseaduseelnou valjatootamise komisjoni koosolek neljapaeval, 28. jaanuaril 1937 kell 5 pl. Riigikantselei koosolekute saalis [Minutes No 41. The meeting of the Committee for the Elaboration of the Draft Constitution, appointed by the State Elder, on Thursday 28 January 1937 at 5 p.m. in the meeting room of the State Chancellery], [in:] Estonian National Archives ERA.31.3.735.
Rahvuskogu teise koja pohiseaduse eelnou uldaruandja A. Anderkopp’i kone Rahvuskogu teise koja koosolekul 6. juulil 1937 [Speech by A. Anderkopp, the General Rapporteur for the draft Constitution of the Second Chamber of the National Assembly, at the meeting of the Second Chamber of the National Assembly on 6 July 1937], [in:] Pohiseadus ja Rahvuskogu [Constitution and National Assembly], Tallinn 1937, pp. 152-168.
Rahvuskogu. Esimene koda. Stenograafilised aruanded [The National Assembly. First Chamber. Stenographic reports], From 19 February to 13 August 1937, Tallinn 1938.
Rytel-Warzocha A., Szmyt A., Current Constitutional changes in Poland Against the Backround of Polish Political and Legal Traditions, “Juridiska zinatne”, No 12. Available https://doi.org/10.22364/jull.12.
Salurand E., Kodanike pohioiguste ja kohustuste kusimusi [Issues of citizen’s basic rights and obligations], “ERK” 1937, vol. 2.
Schulz L., Das Verfassungsrecht Russlands, [in:] “Russlands Aufbruch ins 20. Jahrhundert”, Freiburg 1970.
Siimets-Gross H., Leppik M., Estonia: First Landmarks of Fundamental Rights, [in:] First Fundamental Rights Documents in Europe, eds. M. Suksi, K. Agapiou-Josephides, J.-P. Lehners, M. Nowak, Cambridge–Antwerp–Portland 2015.
Siimets-Gross H., Pohioiguste ja pohikohustuste vahekord Eesti ja Poola pohiseadustes – paralleelne voi vastandlik areng? [The Relationship between Basic Rights and Basic Duties under the Estonian and Polish Constitutions: Parallel or Divergent Development?], “Riigioiguse Aastaraamat (Annual Book of Constitutional Law)” 2021/2.
Siimets-Gross H., Social and economic fundamental rights in Estonian Constitutions between World Wars I and II: a vanguard or rearguard of Europe?, “Juridica International” 2005/10.
Sirge R., Uuest Poola pohiseadusest ja selle ellurakendamisest [The New Polish Constitution and Its Implementation], “Tanapaev” [Today] 1935, vol. 9.
Tonisson J., Rahvakoosolek politiliste oiguste parast. Eesti naitusehoone ruumides [A referendum because of political rights. In the rooms of the Estonian exhibition building.] 30 October 1905, “Postimees” 31 October 1905, No 238.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2021 Miscellanea Historico-Iuridica
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
