Procreation in the Sephardic Jewish Communities of Istanbul, Salonica, and Izmir from 1500-1850
Keywords:
procreation, Salonica, Istanbul, Izmir, fertility, Sephardim, oath of monogamy, polygyny, death, divorce, children, levirate marriageAbstract
The desire to raise a family with as many children as possible was a major aspiration of Jewish families in the Ottoman Empire for centuries. Many halakhic responses and other sources address this subject and its impact on Jewish families and society. This paper reviews how Sephardic Jewish society in the Ottoman cities of Istanbul, Izmir and Salonica (Thessaloniki) grappled with the reality of barren men and women – which was quite common – from 1500-1850, and how Jewish courts resolved cases that involved men’s requests to marry a second wife in order to fulfill the commandment of procreation. It discusses how the desire to procreate was realized through the institution of marriage, the undesirability of single life, the age at marriage, yibum (levirate marriage), women’s desire for children, the impact of kabbalah on fulfillment of the commandments, contraception, fertility treatments, the effect of child mortality on parents, and how the longing for children affected the private life of prominent individuals.
References
Amado Rabbi Y.Y., O'halei yehuda [responsa], Salonica 1821.
Amarillio Rabbi A., Penei aharon [responsa], Salonica 1796.
Amarillio Rabbi M., Devar moshe [responsa], Vol. 3, Salonica 1750.
Amarillio Rabbi S., Kerem shlomo [responsa], Salonica 1719.
Aminoah N., R. Shelomo Duran's Solution of Matrimonial Problems in the Algerian Jewish Community, “Te'euda” 1997, no. 13 (Hebrew).
Assis Y.T, Sexual Behavior in Medieval Hispano-Jewish Society, [in:] Jewish History, Essays in Honor of Ch. Abramsky, A. Rapoport-Albert, S.Z. Zipperstein (Eds.), London 1998.
Assis Y.T., The 'Ordinance of Rabbenu Gershom' and Polygamous Marriages in Spain, “Zion” 1981, no. 46 (Hebrew).
Bashan E., Breastfeeding in Jewish Law and Literature, Lod 2014 (Hebrew).
Ben-Naeh Y., A Tested and Tried Spell: Magical Beliefs and Actions among the Jews of the Ottoman Empire", Pe'amim, 85 (2001), pp. 89-111 (Hebrew).
Ben-Naeh Y., Blond, Tall, with Honey-Colored Eyes: Jewish Ownership of Slaves in the Ottoman Empire, “Jewish History” 2006, no. 20, ¾.
Ben-Naeh Y., Marriages of Minors among Jews in the Ottoman Empire, “Zemanim” 2008, no. 102 (Hebrew).
Benveniste Rabbi Moshe, Penei moshe [responsa], Vol. 3, Constantinople 1719.
Bornstein-Makovetsky L., Adultery and Punishment Among Jews in the Ottoman Empire, “Jewish Law Association Studies” 2014, vol. XXV.
Bornstein-Makovetsky L., Divorce and Remarriage in Jewish Society in the Ottoman Empire in the 18th and 19th Centuries, “East and Maghreb” 2004, vol. VII (Hebrew).
Bornstein-Makovetsky L., Extramarital Relations among Jews in the Ottoman Empire, “Miscellanea Historico-Iuridica” 2014, vol. 13.
Bornstein-Makovetsky L., Marriage and Divorce in the Jewish Society of Istanbul in the Eighteenth and Nineteenth Centuries, “Michael” 1997, vol. 14 (Hebrew).
Bornstein-Makovetsky L., Ottoman and Jewish Authorities Facing Issues of Fornication and Adultery: 1700-1900, “International Journal of the Jurisprudence of the Family” 2013, vol. 4.
Bornstein-Makovetsky L., The Jewish Family in Istanbul in the 18th and 19th Centuries as an Economic Unit, [in:] Sexuality and Family in History, I. Bartal I, I. Gafni (Eds.), Jerusalem 1998 (Hebrew).
Cohen J., Be Fertile and Increase, Fill the Earth and Master It. The Ancient and Medieval Career of a Biblical Text, New York 1989.
Covo Rabbi Y. H, Kochav me-yaakov [responsa], Salonica 1915.
Crespin Rabbi Moshe Mordechai, Maim kedoshim, Vol. 2, Izmir 1852.
Crespin Rabbi Y., Shemo yitzhak [responsa], Smyrna: Haim Abraham 1893.
De Medina Rabbi S, Maharashdam [responsa], Lvov 1862.
Di Toledo Rabbi E, Mishnat rabbi eliezer [responsa], Vol. 1, Salonica: Bezalel Halevi Ashkenazi 1853; Vol. 2, Smyrna: Roditi 1865.
Donohue J. J, Esposito J.L., Islam in Transition: Muslim Perspectives, New York 1982.
Elyashar Rabbi Y.S., Book of Jerusalem Taqqanot, Jerusalem 1883 (Hebrew).
Esterosa Rabbi A., Yerech avraham [responsa], 2 vols, Salonica: Molcho 1815.
Feldman W.M., Birth Control in Jewish Law, New York 1995.
Florentin Rabbi S., Olat shmuel, Salonica 1776.
Fresco Rabbi M., Yadav shel moshe [responsa], Salonica: Saadi Halevi 1812.
Grossman A., Pious and rebellious, Jewish Women in Medieval Europe, Brandeis University Press 2004.
Hacker J.R., Pride and Depression - Polarity of the Spiritual and Social Experience of the Iberian Exiles in the Ottoman Empire, [in:] Culture and Society in Medieval Jewry, M. Ben-Sasson, R. Bonfil, J.R. Hacker (Eds.), Jerusalem 1989 (Hebrew).
Hacohen, Rabbi S., Maharshach [responsa], Vol. 1, Jerusalem 1961; Vol. 2, Venice 1592; Vol. 4, Salonica 1652.
Hacohen ha'itamari, Rabbi E., Shevet mussar, Amsterdam 1735.
Halevi Rabbi S., Lev shlomo [responsa], Salonica 1808.
Hazan Rabbi Y, Hikrei lev [responsa], Vol. 4, Even ha'ezer, Salonica: Saadi Halevi Ashkenazi 1813.
Heinemann J, Kadish, “Hebrew Encyclopedia” 1977, vol. 29 (Hebrew).
Ibn Avi Zimra Rabbi D., Radbaz [responsa], Vol. 3, Fiorda 1781.
Ibn Haim Rabbi E., Re'anah [responsa], Venice 1610.
Ibn Lev Rabbi Y, Maharival [responsa], Vol. 1, Amsterdam 1726.
Ibn Sanji Rabbi Y., Be'erot hamaim [responsa], Salonica 1857.
Israel Rabbi E., Kol eliyahu [responsa], Livorno 1792.
Katz J., Halakha and Kabbalah, Studies in the History of Jewish Religion, its Various Faces and Social Relevance, Jerusalem 1984 (Hebrew).
Kauffman T., Brenner I., Narrative and Normative Discourse in the Sugiyot of Procreation, “Jerusalem Studies in Jewish Thought” 2017, vol. 25 (Hebrew).
Lamdan R., A Separate People: Jewish Women in Palestine, Syria and Egypt in the Sixteenth Century, Leiden, Boston 8; Köln 2000.
Lamdan R., Hatred, Jealousy and Compromise in Ottoman-Jewish Society in Early Modern Times, “Masechet” 2017, vol. 13 (Hebrew).
Lamdan R., Mothers and Children as seen by Sixteenth Century Rabbis in the Ottoman Empire, [in:] Sephardi Family Life in the Early Modern Diaspora, R. Julia, R. Lieberman (Ed.), Waltham 2011.
Maimon Rabbi Moshe (Maimonides), Sefer hamitzvot (Book of Commandments), Jerusalem 1995.
Maimon Rabbi Moshe (Maimonides), Mishne torah, Haifa 2013-2014.
Marcus A., The Middle East on the Eve of Modernity: Aleppo in the Eighteenth Century, New York 1989.
Marienberg E., Female Fertility in Talmudic Literature, “Hebrew Union College Annual” 2013-2014, vol. 84-85 (Hebrew).
Matalon Rabbi S., Avodat hashem [responsa], Salonica 1893.
Menachem (Frangi) Rabbi H., Mate lehem [responsa], Vol. 1, Constantinople 1902.
Menashe Rabbi R.Y., Be'er hamaim [responsa], Salonica 1836.
Meyuhas Rabbi A., Benei avraham [responsa], Constantinople: Shmuel Ashkenazi 1773.
Meyuhas-Ginio, A., Meam Loez (1730): Daily Life of Sephardic Families in Jerusalem, [in:] Women, Children and the Elderly, Essays in Honour of Shulamit Shahar, M. Eliav-Feldon, Y. Hen (Eds.), Jerusalem 2001 (Hebrew).
Mizrahi Rabbi E., Re'em [responsa], Constantinople 1560.
Mizrahi Rabbi M., Admat kodesh, Vol. 1, Constantinople 1742.
Moda'i Rabbi H, Haim le'olam [responsa], Vol. 2, Izmir 1879.
Moda'i Rabbi N. H. M., Meimar haim [responsa], [in:] Moda'i Rabbi H., Haim le'olam, Vol. 2, Izmir 1879.
Modiliani Rabbi Y. S., Rosh mashbir [responsa], Vol. 1, Salonica 1721.
Moziri Rabbi H. N. R., Be'er mayim haim [responsa], Salonica 1794.
Musafia Rabbi H. Y., Haim vahesed [responsa], Vol. 1-2, Livorno 1844; Jerusalem 1987.
Navaro Rabbi Y., Lev mevin, Salonica: Bezalel Halevi 1817.
Pachter M., Mizefunot zefat, Jerusalem 1994 (Hebrew).
Palage Rabbi A., Avraham et yado [sermons], Izmir 1886.
Palage Rabbi A., Avraham shenit, [in:] Idem., Zakote de'avraham, Izmir 1890.
Palage Rabbi A., Shema avraham, Vol. 1-2 [responsa], Salonika 1850, 1851.
Palage Rabbi A., Vayaan avraham [responsa], Izmir 1886.
Palage Rabbi H., Ginzei haim, Izmir 1871.
Palage Rabbi H., Ḥayim veshalom [responsa], Vol, 1-2, Izmir 1857, 1872.
Palage Rabbi H, Ru'ah ḥaim [responsa], 2 vols., Smyrna 1876-1877.
Presco Rabbi M, Yadav shel moshe [responsa], Salonica 1812.
Regev S., Sermons of Rabbi Isaac Caro, Ramat Gan 1996 (Hebrew).
Rosner F., Contraception in Jewish Law, [in:] FJewish Bioethics, . Rosner, D.J.D. Bleich (Eds.), New York 1979.
Rozen M., A History of the Jewish Community in Istanbul, The Formative Years, 1453-1566, Leiden-Boston 2002.
Rozen M., The Death of Precious Women: The Tombstones of Upper-Class Jewish Women in Eighteenth-Century Istanbul, “Pe'amim” 2017, vol. 150-152 (Hebrew).
Rozen M., The Life Cycle and the Significance of Old Age During the Ottoman Period, [in:] Daniel Carpi Jubilee Volume, D. Porat, M. Rozen, A. Shapira A (Eds.), Tel Aviv 1996.
Schremer A., Male and Female He Created Them: Jewish Marriage in Late Second Temple, Mishnah and Talmud Periods, Jerusalem 2003 (Hebrew).
Siegel S., Some Aspects of the Jewish Tradition’s View of Sex, [in:] Jews and Divorce, Eighteenth Century, J. Fried, New York 1989.
Ta-Shma I. M., Orphan's Kadish, “Tarbiẕ” 1984, vol. 53 (Hebrew).
Tishby I., The Wisdom of the Zohar (Mishnat haZohar), Vol. 2, Jerusalem 1975 (Hebrew).
Westreich E., Causes for Lifting the Ban of Rabbi Gershom on Polygamy and Compulsory Divorce during the late Middle Ages, “Dinei Israel” 1991-1992, vol. 16 (Hebrew).
Westreich E., The Commandment of Procreation in Jewish Law in the Sixteenth Century Ottoman Empire, “Te'euda” 1997, vol. 13 (Hebrew).
Westreich E., Transitions in the Legal Status of the Wife in Jewish Law – A Journey Among Traditions, Jerusalem 2002 (Hebrew).
Wislicki L., Pregnancy and Birth, [in:] Medical Guide According to Jewish Tradition, L. Wislicki (Ed.), Jerusalem 1977 (Hebrew).
Yahalom S., Moch: Family Planning in the Jewish Communities of France and Catalonia in the Middle Ages, “Pe'amim” 2011, vol. 128 (Hebrew).
Yekoel, Rabbi Y., Mate Yosef [responsa], Salonica 1785.
Zand Y.Z., Birkat Banim Book (Boy's Blessing Book) on Matters of Fertility and Medicine in Halacha, Jerusalem 1994 (Hebrew).
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2022 Miscellanea Historico-Iuridica
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
