Casuistry, Antiprobabilism and Contracts: Paolo Comitoli SJ and His Responsa Moralia
Keywords:
contract law, late scholasticism, casuistry, moral theology, probabilismAbstract
Early modern moral theology, that is the so-called second or late scholasticism with its casuistry, dedicated considerable attention to contract law. Theologians approached contracts as a morally significant subject, though they took into account not only theological merits but also the standard legal doctrines, from both civil and canon law. This paper examines the contractual cases of conscience in the Responsa moralia of the Italian Jesuit Paolo Comitoli (1545–1626). This collection of moral cases, spanning over eight hundred pages, covered numerous topics, including contract law.
Although Comitoli was not among the most distinguished scholars of his time, he stood out from his peers as he contributed to both the epistemological debate and the contractual doctrine. His engagement with the former is evident in the widely recognised view that he was – untypically for the Jesuits of his time – an antiprobabilist, meaning he held that in a disputed moral case with dissenting authorities, one should favor the more
probable opinion of the learned authors. His contribution to the latter is demonstrated in his work Doctrina de contractu, where he extensively developed a sophisticated theory of contracts, including a new definition and twelve attributes of a contract.
This paper focuses on the characteristics of Comitoli’s contractual cases and on the application of his epistemological doctrine in contractual casuistry.
References
Ballerini Antonio, Vindiciae Alphonsianae seu doctoris Ecclesiae S. Alphonsi M. de Ligorio episcopi et fundatoris Congrationis SS. Redemptoris Doctrina moralis vindicata, Roma 1873.
Comitoli Paolo, Doctrina de contractu universe ad scientiae methodum revocato in III partes distributa, Lyon 1615.
Comitoli Paolo, Responsa moralia in VII libros digesta, quibus, quae in christiani officii rationibus videntur ardua ac difficilia, enucleantur, Lyon 1609.
Fumi Bartolomeo, Summa aurea armilla nuncupata, Venice 1578.
Gury Jean Pierre, Compendium theologiae moralis, ed. A. Ballerini, Roma 1884, vol. 1.
Neubauer Ignaz, Theologia dogmatico-polemico-scholastica praelectionibus academicis accomodata, vol. 2, Würzburg 1768.
Pascal Blaise, Les Provinciales ou Lettres écrites par Louis de Montalte à un provincial de ses amis et aux RR. PP. Jésuites sur le sujet de la morale et de la politique de ces Pères, ed. C. Louandre, Paris 1862.
Summenhart Konrad, Opus septipertitum de contractibus pro foro conscientiae atque theologico, Hagenau 1500.
Terill Anthony, Regula morum sive tractatus bipartitus de sufficienti ad conscientiam rite formandam regula, Liège 1677.
Alexandrowicz Piotr, Libertas contractus. Paolo Comitoli SJ on Freedom of Contract, “Czasopismo Prawno-Historyczne” 2021, vol. 73(1), pp. 181–201.
Alexandrowicz Piotr, Paolo Comitoli SJ on Contracts, “Zeitschrift der Savigny-Stiftung für Rechtsgeschichte: Kanonistische Abteilung” 2021, vol. 107, pp. 255–299.
Anonymous, rev., Le journal de sçavants, Paris 1709, pps. 727–729 [from:] Paolo Comitoli, Responsa moralia in VII. libros digesta (…) Doctrina de contractu universe ad scientiae methodum revocato (…), Rouen 1709.
Astrain Antonio, Historia de la Compañía de Jesús en la asistencia de España, vol. 6: Nickel, Oliva, Noyelle, González, Madrid 1920.
de Backer Augustin, Comitolus, Paul, [in:] Bibliothèque des écrivains de la Compagnie de Jésus: ou Notices bibliographiques, eds A. de Backer et al., vol. 1, Liège 1869, col. 1344–1345.
Bernard P., Comitoli Paul, [in:] Dictionnaire de théologie catholique: contenant l’exposé des doctrines de la théologie catholique, leurs preuves et leur histoire, eds. E. Mangenot et al., vol. 3, Paris 1908, col. 308.
Birocchi Italo, Comitoli, Paolo, [in:] Dizionario biografico dei giuristi italiani (XII–XX secolo), eds. I. Birocchi et al., vol. 1, Bologna 2013, p. 565.
Condorelli Orazio, Noterelle sparse in tema di fides e bona fides tra diritto canonico e diritto civile nell’età intermedia, [in:] Iura Communia. Scritti in ricordo di Mario Montorzi, eds. D. Edigati and M. P. Geri, Pisa 2022, pp. 195–225.
Decock Wim, Theologians and Contract Law: The Moral Transformation of the Ius Commune (ca. 1500–1650), Leiden–Boston 2013.
Decock Wim, Birr Christiane, Recht und Moral in der Scholastik der Frühen Neuzeit 1500–1750, Berlin 2016.
Deman Thomas, Probabilisme, [in:] Dictionnaire de théologie catholique: contenant l’exposé des doctrines de la théologie catholique, leurs preuves et leur histoire, eds É. Amman et al., vol. 13(1), Paris 1936, col. 417–619.
Donnelly John Patrick, Comitoli, Paolo, [in:] Diccionario histórico de la Compañía de Jesús, eds. C.E. O’Neill et al., vol. 1, Roma 2001, pp. 874–875.
Fleming Julia, Defending Probabilism: The Moral Theology of Juan Caramuel, Washington 2006.
Gay Jean-Pascal, Jesuit Civil Wars: Theology, Politics and Government under Tirso González (1687–1705), London 2016.
Gay Jean-Pascal, La casuistique moderne entre expression et production de norms, [in:] La fabrique de la norme: Lieux et modes de production des normes au Moyen Âge et à l’époque modern, eds. V. Beaulande-Barraud, Rennes 2012, pp. 49–67.
Hurter Hugo, Nomenclator literarius recentioris theologiae Catholicae theologos exhibens, vol. 1, Innsbruck 1872.
Hurtubuise Pierre, La casuistique dans tous ses états: de Martin Azpilcueta à Alphonse de Liguori, Ottawa 2009.
Kantola Ilkka, Probability and Moral Uncertainty in Late Medieval and Early Modern Times, Helsinki 1994.
Maryks Robert A., Saint Cicero and the Jesuits: The Influence of the Liberal Arts on the Adoption of Moral Probabilism, Aldershot 2008.
Müllendorf Julius, Comitolus, Paul, [in:] Wetzer und Welte‘s Kirchenlexikon oder Encyklopädie der katholischen Theologie und ihrer Hülfswissenschaften, eds. J. Hergenröther, F. Kaulen, vol. 3, Freiburg i. B. 1884, col. 690–691.
Schuessler Rudolf, Casuistry and Probabilism, [in:] A Companion to the Spanish Scholastics, eds H. E. Braun et al., Leiden–Boston 2021, pp. 334–360.
Schuessler Rudolf, Moral im Zweifel, vol. 2: Die Herausforderung des Probabilismus, Paderborn 2006.
Schuessler Rudolf, The Debate on Probable Opinions in the Scholastic Tradition, Leiden– Boston 2019.
Schwartz Daniel, Probabilism Reconsidered: Deference to Experts, Types of Uncertainty, and Medicines, “Journal of the History of Ideas” 2014, vol. 75(3), pp. 373–393.
Southwell Nathaniel, PAULUS COMITOLUS, [in:] N. Southwell, Bibliotheca scriptorum Societatis Iesu, apud Iacobi Antonii de Lazzaris Varesii, Roma 1676, p. 647.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Uniwersytet w Białymstoku (entire issue as a whole); Piotr Alexandrowicz (article)
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
