Reliance on International Treaties as a Means of Protecting Minority Rights: An Effective Strategy or Waiting for Nothing? The Case of the Polish Minority in Lithuania
Keywords:
Minority Rights, Discrimination, Language Rights, Political ActionAbstract
This article focuses on the legal and political impact of international minority rights treaties on the Polish minority in Lithuania. An analysis will be made as to whether and to what degree they have been followed by Lithuania, and, overall, whether they have been effective for the Polish minority in Lithuania. The possibility that they are more of a false promise will also be addressed, and whether or not reliance on international law – perhaps in conjunction with local political action within Lithuania – is a good strategy for Poles in Lithuania. In general, international law norms have not had a direct impact, at least as applied by various international tribunals and other bodies. Cases brought by ethnic Poles before the European Court of Justice, the European Court of Human Rights, and the U.N. Human Rights Committee have not yielded significant results. The Framework Convention for the Protection of National Minorities does directly address many of the issues raised by the Polish minority, but it is not enforceable absent enabling legislation. Yet, recent positive domestic legislation and case law in Lithuania have mitigated these concerns, suggesting that political mobilization, using international norms as a benchmark to be obtained, is much more effective than relying on international law on its own.
References
Atchue D., Piercing the Veil of State Laicity In “La Belle Province”: How Québec's Religious Symbols Ban Violates Article 18 of the International Covenant On Civil And Political Rights, “American University International Law Review” 2021, Vol. 37.
Błaszczak J., The implementation of commitments regarding the Polish minority in Lithuania in the Council of Europe’s system, “Border and Regional Studies” 2020, Vol. 8 (3).
Bukaitė V., Pamirštos Paulio Hymanso derybos: Vilniaus krašto klausimas Briuselyje ir Ženevoje 1921m. [Paul Hymans’ Forgotten Negotiations: The Dispute over the Vilnius Region in Brussels and Geneva in 1921], “Lituanistica” 2018, Vol. 64, No 1.
de Búrca G., Beyond The Charter: How Enlargement Has Enlarged The Human Rights Policy Of The European Union, “Fordham International Law Journal” 2004, Vol. 27.
de Varennes F., The Protection of Linguistic Minorities in Europe and Human Rights: Possible Solutions to Ethnic Conflicts?, “Columbia Journal of European Law” 1996, Vol. 2.
Dajani O., Responding to Ethnic and Religious Conflict in the Emerging Arab Order: The Promise and Limits of Rights, “UCLA Journal of International Law and Foreign Affairs” 2013, Vol. 17.
Davy U., How Human Rights Shape Social Citizenship: On Citizenship and the Understanding of Economic and Social Rights, “Washington University Global Studies Law Review” 2014, Vol. 13.
Defeis E., Minority Protections and Bilateral Agreements: An Effective Mechanism, “Hastings International and Comparative Law Review” 1999, Vol. 22.
Fellmeth A., Nondiscrimination as a Universal Human Right, “Yale Journal of International Law” 2009, Vol. 34.
Frėjutė-Rakauskienė M., Sasunkevich O., Šliavaite K., Polish Ethnic Minority in Belarus and Lithuania: Politics, Institutions, and Identities, “Nationalities Papers” 2021, Vol. 49: 6.
Furtado Jr. C., Guess Who's Coming to Dinner? Protection for National Minorities in Eastern And Central Europe under the Council of Europe, “Columbia Human Rights Law Review” 2003, Vol. 34.
Herrmann J., Implementing the Prohibition of Torture on Three Levels: The United Nations, the Council of Europe, and Germany, “Hastings International and Comparative Law Review” 2008, Vol. 31.
Jabareen Y., Linguistic Rights for Minorities and the Quest for Equality: The Case of Arab-Palestinians in Israel, “University of Pennsylvania Journal of Law and Social Change” 2022, Vol. 25.
Kazėnas G., Lithuanian Polish Political Party in Parliamentary Election 2016 in Lithuania, “Political Preferences” 2017, vol. 14.
Korkeakivi A., In Defense of Speaking Out: The European Human Rights Regime and the Protection of Minority Languages, “Intercultural Human Rights Law Review” 2008, Vol. 3.
Langer L., Panacea or Pathetic Fallacy? The Swiss Ban on Minarets, “Vanderbilt Journal of Transnational Law” 2010, Vol. 43.
Leviter L., The ASEAN Charter: ASEAN Failure or Member Failure?, “New York University Journal of International Law and Politics” 2010, Vol. 43.
Lubamersky L., National Self-Perception Among the Lithuanian Nobility: Evidence from the Radziwiłł Family, “Journal of Baltic Studies” 2001, Vol. 32, No. 1.
Mickonytė A., The Right to a Name Versus National Identity in the Context of EU Law: The Case of Lithuania, “Review of Central and East European Law” 2017, Vol. 42.
Mieńkowska-Norkiene R., The Political Impact of the Case Law of the Court of Justice of the European Union, “European Constitutional Law Review” 2021, Vol. 17.
Ratner S., Does International Law Matter in Preventing Ethnic Conflict?, “New York University Journal of International Law and Politics” 2000, Vol. 32.
Saunders P., The Integrated Enforcement Of Human Rights, “New York University Journal of International Law and Politics” 2012, Vol. 45.
Shany Y., Assessing the Effectiveness of International Courts: A Goal-Based Approach, “American Journal of International Law” 2012, Vol. 106.
Slaughter A., Judicial Globalization, “Virginia Journal of International Law” 2000, Vol. 40.
Tsiros D., The “Ouzo” Case: Towards a New Assessment of Member State Obligations under the Treaty and the Commission's Discretion in the Exercise of Public Enforcement, “Columbia Journal of European Law” 2006, Vol. 12.
Walkowiak J., One Word, Two Languages, Two Interpretations: The Polish-Lithuanian Treaty of 1994 and How it Was (Mis)Understood, “Comparative Legilinguistics” 2014, Vol. 18.
Jedrzejewicz W., Pilsudski: A Life for Poland, New York 1982.
Kiaupa Z., The History of Lithuania, Vilnius 2002.
Liekis S., 1939: The Year that Changed Everything in Lithuania’s History, Amsterdam 2010.
Lukowski J., Liberty's Folly: The Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth in the Eighteenth Century, 1697-1795, London 1991.
Macmillan M., Paris 1919, New York 2001.
Snyder T., The Reconstruction of Nations: Poland, Ukraine, Lithuania, Belarus, 1569-1999, New Haven 2003.
Adalah, et. al. v. The Municipalities of Tel Aviv-Jaffa, et. al., Supreme Court of Israel, 25 July 2002, H.C. 4112/99.
Ballantyne, Davidson, McIntyre v. Canada, Human Rights Committee, Communications Nos. 359/1989 and 385/1989, U.N. Doc. CCPR/C/47/D/359/1989 and 385/1989/Rev.1 (1993).
Belgian Linguistics Case, European Court of Human Rights, July, 1968, (1979-80) 1 E.H.R.R. 252.
Cytacka v. Lithuania, European Court of Human Rights, July 10, 2012, Application no. 53788/08.
García Avello, European Court of Justice, 2003, Case C-148/02 [2003].
Grunkin and Paul, European Court of Justice, 2008, Case C-353/06 [2008].
Kleckovski v Lithuania, Human Rights Committee, 2007, Comm 1285/2004 (HRC 2007).
Konstantinidis, European Court of Justice, 1993, Case C-168/91 [1993] ECR I1191.
Mentzen v Latvia, European Court of Human Rights, December 12, 2004, Application No.71074/01.
Raihman v Latvia, Human Rights Committee, 2010, Comm 1621/2007 (HRC 2010).
Runevič-Vardyn, European Court of Justice, May, 2011, C-391/09.
Sayn-Wittgenstein, European Court of Justice, 2010, Case C-208/09 [2010].
Advisory Committee on the Framework Convention for the Protection of National Minorities, ACFC/OP/IV(2018)004, Fourth Opinion on Lithuania - adopted on 30 May 2018, at: https://rm.coe.int/4th-advisory-commitee-opinion-on-lithuania-english-language-version/1680906d97.
Council of Europe, Chart of Signatures and Ratifications of Treaty 157, at: https://www.coe.int/en/web/conventions/full-list?module=signatures-by-treaty&treatynum=157.
Council of Europe, Chart of Signatures and Ratifications of Treaty 177, at: https://www.coe.int/en/web/conventions/full-list?module=signatures-by-treaty&treatynum=177.
Council of Europe, Chart of Signatures and Ratifications of Treaty 005, at: https://www.coe.int/en/web/conventions/full-list?module=signatures-by-treaty&treatynum=005.
European Foundation of Human Rights, The President of Lithuania signed a bill concerning the writing of names and surnames in the Latin alphabet in Lithuanian documents (Jan. 2022)(hereinafter “Surname Bill”), at: https://en.efhr.eu/2022/01/25/the-president-of-lithuania-signed-a-bill/.
European Foundation of Human Rights, A victory secured by the EFHR – the Court ruled that surnames could be registered in their original form using a character with the diacritical mark “ń”, (Feb. 2022), at: https://en.efhr.eu/2022/02/04/a-victory-secured-by-the-efhr-the-court-ruled-that-surnames-could-be-registered-in-their-original-form-using-a-character-with-the-diacritical-mark-n/.
Hyndle-Hussein J., Lithuania: A new government coalition with the participation of the Polish minority party, Centre for Eastern Studies, at: https://www.osw.waw.pl/en/publikacje/analyses/2019-07-10/lithuania-a-new-government-coalition-participation-polish-minority.
Lewandowska I., Sąd potwierdził: Oryginalny zapis imienia także dla Polaków z Litwy, “Kurier Wilenski” 2019, October 24, at: https://kurierwilenski.lt/2019/10/24/sad-potwierdzil-oryginalny-zapis-imienia-takze-dla-polakow-z-litwy/.
Neuman G., Giving Meaning and Effect to Human Rights: The Contributions of Human Rights
Committee Members, HRP 16-02 (Dec. 2016), at: http://hrp.law.harvard.edu/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/Gerald-L-Neuman_HRP-16_002.pdf.
Official Statistics Portal, at: https://osp.stat.gov.lt/en_GB/gyventoju-ir-bustu-surasymai1.
United Nations Treaty Collection, at: https://treaties.un.org/Pages/ViewDetails.aspx?chapter=4&clang=_en&mtdsg_no=IV-4&src=IND.
Advisory Committee on the Framework Convention for the Protection of National Minorities ACFC/SR/V(2021)004, Fifth Report submitted by Lithuania, Pursuant to Article 25, paragraph 2 of the Framework Convention for the Protection of National Minorities – received on 19 July 2021.
Consolidated versions of the Treaty on European Union and the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union [2016] OJ C202/1 (TFEU).
Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms, Protocol 1, art. 3., Nov. 4, 1950, Europ. T.S. No. 5.
Framework Convention for the Protection of National Minorities, Feb. 1, 1995, E.T.S. 157.
International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR), Dec. 19, 1966, 999 U.N.T.S. 171.
Protocol to the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms (ETS No. 009), at Article 2.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2022 Miscellanea Historico-Iuridica
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
